Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Ugly Side of Langkawi Mangrove Tours Part I - Mat Rempits



Tourists visiting Langkawi were told that their visit will not be complete without having experienced the island's magical mangroves. Very true. 
When a tourist arrives at Langkawi airport or jetty, the tourist will be handed with flyers after flyers for things to do on the island. Pick up any one of those flyers and these words will be staring at your face. "Mangroves Cruise"; "Mangroves Safari";"River Cruise";"Fish Farm";"Bat Cave";"Crocodile Cave" and the worst "Eagle Feeding". With such heavy promotions and raving about the mangroves, tourists would definitely be  looking forward to partake in it. Tourists can pick a boat from the Kilim or Tanjung Rhu jetty and will be enthralled by a two or three hour ride even without a guide onboard.
Langkawi was bestowed with the land and sea forests surrounded by prehistoric fossils and rock formations since some millions of years ago. Her mangroves were groomed well with the amazing karstic features of Setul formation that formed about 45o million years ago. Having such blessed natural heritage, Langkawi has became popular among the tourists that love to spend their holiday relaxing in the serenity of nature. The result of the high influx of tourists to the island has created many lucrative job opportunities for the locals. Over the years, many of the locals that were into fisheries and agriculture had embarked into tourism related jobs such as taxi, bus drivers, restaurant and boat operators. Then gradually, Langkawi has gained a higher status to become a UNESCO heritage site in mid 2007 and is now known as Langkawi Geopark. 
With the Geopark status, the amount of tourists coming in has doubled or if not, almost tripled. This benefits the island with such huge economic boom and yet I am witnessing the sufferings of Langkawi's flora and fauna that they have to bear daily.

Great supply of tourists resulted in mushrooming of operators particularly for the mangroves. The latest craze was the 1km traffic congestion at Kilim jetty due to tourists waiting for availability of boats to take them out. Welcome to the school holidays and festive season!

While there were lots of tourists waiting to go for the mangroves tour, boat skippers were often instructed to cover a route with various stopovers very quickly and to return to jetty for the next tourists pickup. As such, these boats will speed like F1 drivers in the mangroves so they can make as many trips as they can for a day. More trips=more $$$.
No doubt that mangroves are able to adapt in the soft unstable soil. However, constant slamming of waves created by the speeding boats will accelerate the action of mud to be washed off from the banks causing sediments run-off. The consequences will be erosion that had caused some of the trees to collapse. Sediments run-off can pose hazard to the health of the coral reefs that reside along the coastal areas. Mud carried out to the sea by the current will eventually be settled onto the reefs, shading the reefs from sunlight and eventually killing them. 



Speeding boats not only pose hazards to the mangroves forest but also to other users of the mangroves such as the slower boats and kayaks. There were incidents whereby speeding boats turning into the sharp corners had collided with other boats. Luckily there were no mishaps.
There was another  incident whereby a boat was almost tipped over by big waves caused by an overloaded twin-engine boat that was speeding like Michael Schumacher. Because these operators are now so used to speeding in the mangroves, this habit had been formed and  is hard to die. They even speed during the low tourists season.
This is what I find difficult for me to understand about locals here. Tourists make their way to Langkawi because of what the island can offer best. Langkawi will never be a destination for shopping even though it is a duty free island because people come here for nature.  If these operators are allowed to continuously behave like "Mat Rempit" in the mangroves, all I can say is that these locals are breaking their own rice bowls. Check out what Mat Rempit means.
The good news is that there are also responsible companies offering passionate nature guides that conduct nature excursions in an ethical manner. You will expect to pay more for these excursions, however, the investment you make will return you with educational and informative experiences and not just fun boat joy rides. Example of a company will be 
This is the first part of this topic of my blog. Coming next will be my viewpoints on eagle feeding, wildlife feeding and what influences tourists have over ecotourism.

5 comments:

  1. Let's hope people read this and will be led to such information anytime they search content about Langkawi and/or South-East asia's mangroves !

    I could not agree more than I do with Your statements and warnings, WChinner.
    I got struck by this genuine environment. And You learn fast to know how much being genuine may cost.

    I had been warned that Langkawi suffers a very high touristic pressure. Indeed ! And tourists, as usual, concentrate on very limited areas, being transported from here to there, dropped on the site, and then brought away to another site.

    Should I be pessimistic, then I would say this is fatality and nothing can change it.
    So far, I prefer to state that this is a PUBLIC ISSUE.
    By the way, UNESCO sticked a label; so now, not just islanders, not just the local authorities, but also international Organisations hold a responsibility.

    I saw many signs and warnings about the preservation of the island, while riding around Langkawi; more than I ever saw in Indonesia. Though, the side of the road is still paved with plastic bottles and used batteries, just thrown away from fast-driving cars.

    All this is so depressing. Not just the plastic bottles, but the fact that so many people may be so careless while they either depend on their environment to live, or pretend they are here for the Beauty of Nature.

    One thing is to watch TV and "booooh!" to Global Warning; another thing is to think simple and ask to oneself : what can be my personal and immediate contribution to protect everybody's environment ?

    - refuse plastic bags from the shops in Langkawi. You don't need them.
    - bring Your trash back with You and make sure they will be handled as properly as can be.
    - disagree with practices that make You uncomfortable, as soon as You become aware of their bad effects.
    - make sure the operators You contract with share Your views. If they don't, then look for others.
    - avoid the use of AC system or fans in Your hotel or guest-house. You are here because the weather is hot, right ?
    - react publicly and publish as much as You can to keep the pressure on authorities so that they will have to create and enforce laws more likely to preserve.

    Francois Paufique.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Francois;
    Thank you for your comments. Wish there are more responsible tourists like you.

    Will be awaiting to look at your nice photos of our mangroves :)

    There are also some superb non-touristic area in langkawi. Whenever you return, take you there-lah.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good to see you are taking the time to highlight these issues. Personally if I wanted to see tame monkeys (mentioned in part 2)I would go to a zoo. The speeding boats are terrible and thank you for naming tour businesses that conduct themselves in a more appropriate manner...more power to them I say!
    Also thank you for your comments Francois... you raise some very valid points!
    Cheers Russ

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Russell;
    Thank you for putting in your comments.
    Should you be planning to visit the beautiful Langkawi, please feel free to contact me for any tips and advise particularly on nature related sighting seeings.
    We hope to raise as much awareness as possible to tourists that come here.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi WChinner,

    I agree with you. Langkawi's fragile ecosystems are being indiscriminately exploited by the local tourism operators and developers with lower-than average eco-sustainability actions.

    Unfriendly actions such as speeding of boats are likely to discourage tourists from visiting especially those that are more environmentally cautious. Boaters were seen buzzing across the rivers and some environmentally sensitive limestone hills were blasted for tourism developments.

    This sort of problems will likely see Langkawi's proud status as a UNESCO Geopark be dropped by UN if such conditions prevailed. And the tourism will suffer and probably even to the brink of collapse under such circumstances. Ultimately, the locals are the ones who pay the price for being who they were. But, with a glimmer of hope and a little twitching of perspectives for the locals, I am confident this will never be allowed to occur.

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
There was an error in this gadget